About the Status of Law Norms
Main Article Content
Abstract
This article analyzes the problem of recommendatory norms in Russian literature, both Soviet and modern, which is solved ambiguously. As for Soviet theoretical scientists, recommendation norms were the subject of study by such authors as Nikolai Grigorievich Alexandrov, Alexander Filippovich Shebanov, Peter Yemelyanovich Nedbailo, Vladimir Srgeevich Petrov, Valery Evaldovich Krasnyansky. Viktor Mikhailovich Gorshenev, Cecilia Abramovna Yampolskaya, Vladimir Matveevich Solyanik, Viktor Lavrenievich Kulapov, whose scientific works are given below. Regarding modern legal literature, unfortunately, we have to state that, basically, with rare exceptions (scientific articles by Vladimir Valentinovich Kozhevnikov, Alexander Evgenievich Kondratyev, Sadri Salikhovich Kuzakbirdiev), this problem is considered only in educational literature. When preparing a scientific article, the following methods were used: general philosophical (dialectical-materialistic), which is used in all social sciences; general scientific (analysis and synthesis, logical and historical, comparisons, abstractions, etc.), which are used not only by the theory of state and law, but also by other social sciences; special methods (philological, cybernetic, psychological, etc.), developed by special sciences and widely used for the knowledge of state and legal phenomena; private scientific (formal legal, interpretation of law, etc.), which are developed by the theory of state and law. Soviet scientists - legal theorists: supporters and opponents of the recognition of recommendatory norms of law. From the point of view of scientists, a "recommendatory" -containing recommendation, i.e. advice, wish [1], instruction [2].
Article Details
How to Cite
Kozhevnikov, V. V. (2021). About the Status of Law Norms. Polit Journal Scientific Journal of Politics, 1(2), 58-68. https://doi.org/10.33258/polit.v1i2.445
Section
Articles
References
[1]. Ozhegov Sergey Ivanovich. Dictionary of the Russian language. Moscow: Russian language, 1984, p. 587.
[2]. Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary / Ch. ed. Alexander Mikhailovich Prokhorov. M.: Soviet Encyclopedia, 1986, p. 1117.
[3]. Alexandrov Nikolay Grigorievich. Law and legality in the period of developed socialism. M.: Gosyurizdat, 1961, p. 200
[4]. Shebanov Alexander Filippovich. The norms of socialist law // Theory of state and law: textbook / otv. ed. Nikolay Grigorievich. Alexandrov. M .: Jurid. liter, 1974, p. 476.
[5]. Ioffe Olympiad Solomonovich. Legal norms and human actions // Actual problems of Soviet civil law. M.: Jurid. liter, 1964, p. 32.
[6]. Golunsky Sergey Alexandrovich. On the question of the concept of a legal norm in the theory of socialist law // Sov. state and right. 1961. No 4, p.31-32.
[7]. Nedbailo Petr Emelyanovich. Application of Soviet legal norms, Moscow: Gosyurizdat, 1960, p. 85.
[8]. Petrov Vladimir Sergeevich, Krasnyansky Valery Evaldovich. Norms of law // General theory of state and law in 2 volumes // otv. ed. Vladimir Sergeevich Petrov, Lev Samoilovich. Yavich. L.: Leningrad University, 1974. Vol. 2: General theory of law, p.270.
[9]. Gorshenev Victor Mikhailovich. Methods and organizational forms of legal regulation in a socialist society. M.: Jurid. liter, 1972, p. 87.
[10]. Theoretical questions of the systematization of the Soviet legislation. M.: Gosyurizdat, 1962, pp. 42-43.
[11]. Yampolskaya Cecilia Abramovna. On persuasion and coercion in Soviet administrative law // Questions of Soviet administrative and financial law Moscow: Publishing house of the USSR Academy of Sciences, 1952, pp. 169-170.
[12]. Shatkov Gennady Ivanovich. Soviet legal norm // Abstract. Cand. dis. jurid. Sci. L.: Leningrad State University. un-t, 1962, p. 10.
[13] .Usenko Evgeny Trofimovich. On the legal nature of the recommendation of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance // Sov. state and right. 1963. No.12, p.86-94
[14]. Mitskevich Alexey Valentinovich. The nature of recommendatory normative prescriptions in the acts of the government of the USSR // Jurisprudence. 1966. No. 2, p.24-25.
[15]. Dzarasov Soltan Safarbievich. Management of socialist production. Moscow: Economics, 1976, p. 144.
[16]. Pashkov Alexey Stepanovich. Soviet labor law. M.: Jurid. literature, 1976, p. 41.
[17]. Alexandrov Nikolay Grigorievich. Legal and industrial relations in a socialist society // Problems of Philosophy. 1957. No 1, p.50.
[18]. Sorokin Valentin Dmitrievich. Method of legal regulation (theoretical problems). M.: Jurid. liter, 1976, pp. 89, 109.
[19]. Solyanik Vladimir Matveevich. State recommendations and labor regulation of workers and employees // Jurisprudence. 1977.No. 6, pp. 111-113, 114.
[20]. Alekseev Sergei Sergeevich. Problems of the theory of law in 2 volumes. Sverdlovsk: Sverdlovsk jurid. Institute, 1972, vol. 1, p. 215.
[21]. Livshits Roman Zinovievich. Legal forms of labor incentives // State, law, economy. Moscow: Moscow worker, 1970, p. 455.
[22]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. Recommended norms of Soviet law: monograph / ed. Mikhail Iosifovich. Baytin. Saratov, 1987, pp. 34, 38, 43, 59.
[23]. Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Andrey Ivanovich Denisov. M., 1972, p. 395.
[24]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. On the question of the legal nature of recommendatory norms // Actual problems of Soviet legal science: Collection of scientific articles. Saratov: Saratov University, 1978, Part 1, pp. 30-31, 33.
[25]. Dembo Lev Isaakovich. Review of the book by Ivan Vasilievich Pavlova Legal forms of business management in collective farms // Sov. state and right. 1956. No. 2, p. 143
[26]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. Classification of recommendatory norms of Soviet law // Questions of the theory of state and law. Actual problems of the theory of the socialist state and law: interuniversity. scientific. Sat. Saratov: Saratov University, 1983, pp. 137-143.
[27]. Babaev Vladimir Konstantinovich. Norms of law // Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev, Moscow, 2007, p. 410
[28]. Abdulaev Magomet Imranovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M .: Economics, 2006, pp. 323-324.
[29]. Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Norms of law // Teriya state and law: a course of lectures / ed. Mikhail Nikolaevich Marchenko, Moscow: Zertsalo, 1997, pp. 376-377.
[30]. Baytin Mikhail Iosifovich. The essence of law (Modern normative legal thinking on the verge of two centuries): monograph. M., Publishing house "Law and State" 2005, p.256.
[31]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich, Kondratyev Alexander Evgenievich. On some problems of the concept and implementation of recommendatory norms (in the context of the interaction of national and international law) // Modern Law. 2015. No. 10, pp. 5-12.
[32]. Kuzakbirdiev Sadri Salikhovich. Form of implementation of recommendatory norms // Scientific notes: Collection of scientific works of the Institute of State and Law. Tyumen: Tyumen State un-t, 2001, p. 53.
[33]. Dyuryagin Ivan Yakovlevich. The norms of Soviet law // Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Sergei Sergeevich Alekseev), Moscow: Jurid. liter, 1985, p. 346.
[34]. Alekseev Sergei Sergeevich. General theory of law: a textbook in 2 volumes. M.: Jurid. liter, 1982, vol. 2, p. 79.
[35]. Komarov Sergey Alexandrovich. General theory of state and law. Saransk: Mordovsky University, 1994, p. 181.
[36]. Drobyazko Stepan Grigorievich, Kozlov Vasily Semenovich. General theory of law: textbook. Minsk: Amalfeya, 2005, p. 192.
[37]. Vengerov Anatoly Borisovich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: New Lawyer, 1998, p. 444.
[38]. Lazarev Valery Vasilievich, Lipen Sergey Vasilievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Spark, 1998, p. 209.
[39]. The norms of Soviet law. Problems of Theory / edited by Mikhail Iosifovich Baytin, Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev. Saratov: Saratov University, 1987, pp. 167-169.
[40]. Babaev Vladimir Konstantinovich. Norms of law // General theory of law: a course of lectures / ed. Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev, N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod High School of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 1993, pp. 293-295.
[41]. Chashchin Alexander Nikolaevich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Delo and Service, 2008, p. 295.
[42]. Smolenskiy Mikhail Borisovich, Borisov Gennady Aleksandrovich, Markhgeim Marina Vasilievna, Tonkov Evgeniy Evgenievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Rostov n / a: Phoenix, 2011, p. 292.
[43]. Perevalov Viktor Dmitrievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Yurayt, 2012, p. 155.
[44]. Okamytny Vitaly Vasilievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: IMPE-PABLISH, 2004, p. 404.
[45]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich, Malko Alexander Vasilievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Norma, 2009, p. 210.
[46]. Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich. Norms of law // Theory of state and law: textbook / otv. ed. Alexander Vasilievich Malko. M .: NORUS, 2008, p. 150.
[47]. Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilievich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Prospect, 2012, p. 193.
[48]. Morozova Lyudmila Alexandrovna. Theory of State and Law. Refresher course in questions and answers. M.: Norma, 2003, p. 132.
[49]. Morozova Lyudmila Alexandrovna. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Eksmo, 2007, p. 232.
[50]. Gorshenev Victor Mikhailovich. Atypical regulatory prescriptions // Sov. state and right. 1978. No. 3, pp. 115, 116.
[51]. Puginsky Boris Ivanovich. About the rule of law // Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 11 "Law", 1999. No 5, pp.33. 23-33.
[52]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. Theory of state and law: a textbook in 2 parts. Moscow: Prospect, 2021, part 2, p. 148.
[53]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. On the structure of specialized norms of modern Russian law // Budapest International Institute for Research and Criticism. Vol. 4, No. 1.2021, pp. 1515-1520.
[54]. Filimonov Vadim Donatovich. The norm of law and its functions // State. and right. 2007. No 9, p.6
[55]. Pyanov Nikolai Andreevich. Consulting on the theory of state and law: textbook. Irkutsk: Irkutsk state. un-t, 2010, p. 167.
[56]. Makuev Ruman Kharonovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Norma, 2010, p. 301.
[57]. Larin Alexander Yurievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow, Book World, 2011, p. 136.
[58]. Methodological recommendations on the order of execution of the requirements of executive documents on the recovery of alimony (approved by the FSSP of Russia 19.06. 2012 No. 01-16) // Bulletin of the Federal Service of Bailiffs. 2012. No. 8.
[59]. The decision of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation from 12.01. 2015. No. AKPI14-1289 On the refusal to satisfy the application for recognition as invalid in terms of subparagraphs e and h of paragraph 4 of the Rules for the implementation of activities for the management of apartment buildings // Rulaws. ru /… / (date of access: 19.04.21)
[2]. Soviet Encyclopedic Dictionary / Ch. ed. Alexander Mikhailovich Prokhorov. M.: Soviet Encyclopedia, 1986, p. 1117.
[3]. Alexandrov Nikolay Grigorievich. Law and legality in the period of developed socialism. M.: Gosyurizdat, 1961, p. 200
[4]. Shebanov Alexander Filippovich. The norms of socialist law // Theory of state and law: textbook / otv. ed. Nikolay Grigorievich. Alexandrov. M .: Jurid. liter, 1974, p. 476.
[5]. Ioffe Olympiad Solomonovich. Legal norms and human actions // Actual problems of Soviet civil law. M.: Jurid. liter, 1964, p. 32.
[6]. Golunsky Sergey Alexandrovich. On the question of the concept of a legal norm in the theory of socialist law // Sov. state and right. 1961. No 4, p.31-32.
[7]. Nedbailo Petr Emelyanovich. Application of Soviet legal norms, Moscow: Gosyurizdat, 1960, p. 85.
[8]. Petrov Vladimir Sergeevich, Krasnyansky Valery Evaldovich. Norms of law // General theory of state and law in 2 volumes // otv. ed. Vladimir Sergeevich Petrov, Lev Samoilovich. Yavich. L.: Leningrad University, 1974. Vol. 2: General theory of law, p.270.
[9]. Gorshenev Victor Mikhailovich. Methods and organizational forms of legal regulation in a socialist society. M.: Jurid. liter, 1972, p. 87.
[10]. Theoretical questions of the systematization of the Soviet legislation. M.: Gosyurizdat, 1962, pp. 42-43.
[11]. Yampolskaya Cecilia Abramovna. On persuasion and coercion in Soviet administrative law // Questions of Soviet administrative and financial law Moscow: Publishing house of the USSR Academy of Sciences, 1952, pp. 169-170.
[12]. Shatkov Gennady Ivanovich. Soviet legal norm // Abstract. Cand. dis. jurid. Sci. L.: Leningrad State University. un-t, 1962, p. 10.
[13] .Usenko Evgeny Trofimovich. On the legal nature of the recommendation of the Council for Mutual Economic Assistance // Sov. state and right. 1963. No.12, p.86-94
[14]. Mitskevich Alexey Valentinovich. The nature of recommendatory normative prescriptions in the acts of the government of the USSR // Jurisprudence. 1966. No. 2, p.24-25.
[15]. Dzarasov Soltan Safarbievich. Management of socialist production. Moscow: Economics, 1976, p. 144.
[16]. Pashkov Alexey Stepanovich. Soviet labor law. M.: Jurid. literature, 1976, p. 41.
[17]. Alexandrov Nikolay Grigorievich. Legal and industrial relations in a socialist society // Problems of Philosophy. 1957. No 1, p.50.
[18]. Sorokin Valentin Dmitrievich. Method of legal regulation (theoretical problems). M.: Jurid. liter, 1976, pp. 89, 109.
[19]. Solyanik Vladimir Matveevich. State recommendations and labor regulation of workers and employees // Jurisprudence. 1977.No. 6, pp. 111-113, 114.
[20]. Alekseev Sergei Sergeevich. Problems of the theory of law in 2 volumes. Sverdlovsk: Sverdlovsk jurid. Institute, 1972, vol. 1, p. 215.
[21]. Livshits Roman Zinovievich. Legal forms of labor incentives // State, law, economy. Moscow: Moscow worker, 1970, p. 455.
[22]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. Recommended norms of Soviet law: monograph / ed. Mikhail Iosifovich. Baytin. Saratov, 1987, pp. 34, 38, 43, 59.
[23]. Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Andrey Ivanovich Denisov. M., 1972, p. 395.
[24]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. On the question of the legal nature of recommendatory norms // Actual problems of Soviet legal science: Collection of scientific articles. Saratov: Saratov University, 1978, Part 1, pp. 30-31, 33.
[25]. Dembo Lev Isaakovich. Review of the book by Ivan Vasilievich Pavlova Legal forms of business management in collective farms // Sov. state and right. 1956. No. 2, p. 143
[26]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich. Classification of recommendatory norms of Soviet law // Questions of the theory of state and law. Actual problems of the theory of the socialist state and law: interuniversity. scientific. Sat. Saratov: Saratov University, 1983, pp. 137-143.
[27]. Babaev Vladimir Konstantinovich. Norms of law // Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev, Moscow, 2007, p. 410
[28]. Abdulaev Magomet Imranovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M .: Economics, 2006, pp. 323-324.
[29]. Leist Oleg Ernestovich. Norms of law // Teriya state and law: a course of lectures / ed. Mikhail Nikolaevich Marchenko, Moscow: Zertsalo, 1997, pp. 376-377.
[30]. Baytin Mikhail Iosifovich. The essence of law (Modern normative legal thinking on the verge of two centuries): monograph. M., Publishing house "Law and State" 2005, p.256.
[31]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich, Kondratyev Alexander Evgenievich. On some problems of the concept and implementation of recommendatory norms (in the context of the interaction of national and international law) // Modern Law. 2015. No. 10, pp. 5-12.
[32]. Kuzakbirdiev Sadri Salikhovich. Form of implementation of recommendatory norms // Scientific notes: Collection of scientific works of the Institute of State and Law. Tyumen: Tyumen State un-t, 2001, p. 53.
[33]. Dyuryagin Ivan Yakovlevich. The norms of Soviet law // Theory of state and law: textbook / ed. Sergei Sergeevich Alekseev), Moscow: Jurid. liter, 1985, p. 346.
[34]. Alekseev Sergei Sergeevich. General theory of law: a textbook in 2 volumes. M.: Jurid. liter, 1982, vol. 2, p. 79.
[35]. Komarov Sergey Alexandrovich. General theory of state and law. Saransk: Mordovsky University, 1994, p. 181.
[36]. Drobyazko Stepan Grigorievich, Kozlov Vasily Semenovich. General theory of law: textbook. Minsk: Amalfeya, 2005, p. 192.
[37]. Vengerov Anatoly Borisovich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: New Lawyer, 1998, p. 444.
[38]. Lazarev Valery Vasilievich, Lipen Sergey Vasilievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Spark, 1998, p. 209.
[39]. The norms of Soviet law. Problems of Theory / edited by Mikhail Iosifovich Baytin, Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev. Saratov: Saratov University, 1987, pp. 167-169.
[40]. Babaev Vladimir Konstantinovich. Norms of law // General theory of law: a course of lectures / ed. Vladimir Konstantinovich Babaev, N. Novgorod: Nizhny Novgorod High School of the Ministry of Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation, 1993, pp. 293-295.
[41]. Chashchin Alexander Nikolaevich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Delo and Service, 2008, p. 295.
[42]. Smolenskiy Mikhail Borisovich, Borisov Gennady Aleksandrovich, Markhgeim Marina Vasilievna, Tonkov Evgeniy Evgenievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Rostov n / a: Phoenix, 2011, p. 292.
[43]. Perevalov Viktor Dmitrievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Yurayt, 2012, p. 155.
[44]. Okamytny Vitaly Vasilievich. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: IMPE-PABLISH, 2004, p. 404.
[45]. Kulapov Victor Lavrent'evich, Malko Alexander Vasilievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Norma, 2009, p. 210.
[46]. Lipinsky Dmitry Anatolyevich. Norms of law // Theory of state and law: textbook / otv. ed. Alexander Vasilievich Malko. M .: NORUS, 2008, p. 150.
[47]. Radko Timofey Nikolaevich, Lazarev Valery Vasilievich, Morozova Lyudmila Aleksandrovna. Theory of state and law: textbook. M.: Prospect, 2012, p. 193.
[48]. Morozova Lyudmila Alexandrovna. Theory of State and Law. Refresher course in questions and answers. M.: Norma, 2003, p. 132.
[49]. Morozova Lyudmila Alexandrovna. Theory of State and Law: Textbook), Moscow: Eksmo, 2007, p. 232.
[50]. Gorshenev Victor Mikhailovich. Atypical regulatory prescriptions // Sov. state and right. 1978. No. 3, pp. 115, 116.
[51]. Puginsky Boris Ivanovich. About the rule of law // Bulletin of Moscow University. Series 11 "Law", 1999. No 5, pp.33. 23-33.
[52]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. Theory of state and law: a textbook in 2 parts. Moscow: Prospect, 2021, part 2, p. 148.
[53]. Kozhevnikov Vladimir Valentinovich. On the structure of specialized norms of modern Russian law // Budapest International Institute for Research and Criticism. Vol. 4, No. 1.2021, pp. 1515-1520.
[54]. Filimonov Vadim Donatovich. The norm of law and its functions // State. and right. 2007. No 9, p.6
[55]. Pyanov Nikolai Andreevich. Consulting on the theory of state and law: textbook. Irkutsk: Irkutsk state. un-t, 2010, p. 167.
[56]. Makuev Ruman Kharonovich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow: Norma, 2010, p. 301.
[57]. Larin Alexander Yurievich. Theory of state and law: textbook. Moscow, Book World, 2011, p. 136.
[58]. Methodological recommendations on the order of execution of the requirements of executive documents on the recovery of alimony (approved by the FSSP of Russia 19.06. 2012 No. 01-16) // Bulletin of the Federal Service of Bailiffs. 2012. No. 8.
[59]. The decision of the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation from 12.01. 2015. No. AKPI14-1289 On the refusal to satisfy the application for recognition as invalid in terms of subparagraphs e and h of paragraph 4 of the Rules for the implementation of activities for the management of apartment buildings // Rulaws. ru /… / (date of access: 19.04.21)